8 Comments (and 5 trackbacks)

• #1 by SteadfastOne on June 9th, 2010

  Quote

  

  I can’t give you an exact answer, but I can tell you it doesn’t take much speed to give someone whiplash when they are rear-ended. My 12-year-old son got whiplash at NASCAR Speed Park in a go-cart when he came in to park and another driver, probably going about 10 mph, crashed into the whole row of them.

• #2 by Big D on June 9th, 2010

  Quote

  

  I don’t think there is a “whiplash” speed. 1 mph you’re not really even going to feel the crash. 2 mph yes you did double the speed but no still not a big deal. To put it in perspective most automatic cars idle at 3 to 5 mph with foot off the break. 10 mph it’s possible but I would say still unlikely. If you are asking for you and you got hit at 1 to 2 mph then suck it up you don’t have whiplash stop looking for free money.

• #3 by Blubla on June 9th, 2010

  Quote

  

  1, 2, 10, or faster, depends on what hits you, or what you hit.

• #4 by the BOSS on June 9th, 2010

  Quote

  

  here is a great website with lots of info
  good luck
  After a third of a century of federal standards mandating the safety performance of everything from bumpers to dashboard controls, it might be reasonable to conclude that occupants are walking away from low-speed crashes without significant injury. The opposite is happening: a General Motors study found that many injuries are occurring in crashes at speeds below 8 miles per hour. Indeed, “whiplash” injuries, the soft tissue damage commonly suffered in these low-speed collisions, now account for more than half (53 percent) of all motor vehicle crash-related injuries.

  Although these injuries are typically classified as minor (AIS 1, the least severe rating), 27 percent of the 2.9 million persons who sustain low-speed injuries each year still have neck pain three years later. The injuries often lead to permanent disability, and as one Swedish study concluded, “This could be the case even when the neck injuries are primarily assessed as minor.” A New England Journal of Medicine editorial noted in 1994 that 20 to 40 percent of people with whiplash have symptoms that last for years, and some never recover.

  Although rear end collisions account for only 5 percent of all automobile fatalities, whiplash is both most likely to occur in such collisions and, when it does, more likely to cause permanent damage: one study found that almost one in 10 whiplash victims in rear end collisions are permanently disabled, compared to fewer than 4 in 10 in non-rear end impacts.

  The ‘How’ Debate

  In whiplash, the cervical spine apparently suffers soft tissue damage when the head snaps backward at the same time as the shoulders rebound forward off the seat back during the collision, but the sequence of events is in dispute. Partly this is because the dynamics of low-speed collisions have not been studied as thoroughly as high-speed collisions. A complicating factor is that human head and neck actions are more complex than those of Hybrid III crash test dummies.

  The traditional view – that whiplash occurs when crash forces first flex the neck and then hyperextend it backward – is “both incomplete and inaccurate,” according to Biodynamics Research Corp., which reports that its low-speed tests “suggest a compression-tension injury causation mechanism.” Still other researchers say “the opposite (of flexion-hyperextension) is true,…that flexion sometimes follows the initial extension of the cervical spine.”

  Several factors appear to affect the severity of whiplash:

  • Ramping.When the occupant slides up the seatback during the collision, it adds to the whiplash motion.

  • Gender, Age, Height.Women (probably because their necks tend to be less muscular than men’s) and older and taller people are more likely to sustain the injury.

  • Turning. An occupant whose head is turned to the side may suffer greater injury because the whiplash motion turns the head even more.

  • Awareness. Occupants who were aware of the impending crash suffered fewer neck injuries in one study.

  • Small Cars. Occupants of smaller cars are more likely to suffer whiplash than those in larger cars.

  • Vehicle Stiffness. “Stiff” vehicles that do not absorb sufficient crash forces in low-speed impacts may reduce vehicular damages, but they transmit more crash forces to occupants, increasing the risk of injuries, including whiplash.

  • Seat and Head Restraint Design. Seat and head restraint stiffness and height can aggravate whiplash injuries.

  Whiplash: Faked or Real?

  Auto insurers tend to blame increased whiplash injury claims on fraud. They say up to half of all fraudulent claims are for whiplash, noting that such claims are rising while vehicle damage claims are decreasing. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, while acknowledging that some neck sprains are real, says they are “easy to fake or exaggerate into fraudulent insurance claims” because they do not result from impact with the car’s interior and they often cannot be detected by standard clinical or radiological exams.

  In its 1994 editorial, however, the New England Journal of Medicine pointed to studies that show most people don’t know the symptoms well enough to fake whiplash for profit. In addition:

  • A 1995 Australian study found compelling data that supports an organic basis for chronic whiplash pain.

  • The same study found no evidence that desire for monetary gain affected the prognosis for whiplash patients.

  • Canadian doctors who examined 28 whiplash patients found that the injury “bore a direct etiologic relationship to internal derangements…in [22 of the 25] patients who underwent arthographic investigation.”

  The Australian researchers said the only known way to confirm reliably a patient’s whiplash injury claim is through anesthetic blocks of the affected joints.

  Head Restraints: Solution or Problem?

  Swedish researchers found that over five years, head restraints prevented neck injuries in about one-fourth of the rear-end collisions it reviewed, but concluded that the restraints did not affect the severity or outcome of the injury.

  The head restraint requirement of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has significantly lowered the incidence of crash-related neck injuries since it became law in 1969. The rule, however, allows both fixed and adjustable restraints, and although fixed restraints are more effective and less expensive to install, most U.S. cars have adjustable restraints because, automakers claim, consumers consider them more luxurious. Yet, adjustable restraints are often improperly positioned:

  • General Motors found 83 percent of adjustable head restraints could have been better positioned to protect occupants.

  • The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety found that 65 percent of adjustable restraints weren’t positioned high enough or close enough to the back of occupants’ heads. (The study also found the same problem in almost half of the cars equipped with fixed restraints.)

  • The Insurance Institute rated as “good” the head restraint systems of only five of 164 car models in 1995; 117 were rated “poor,” half of them cars with fixed restraints.

  As early as 1974, NHTSA recommended more closely integrating head restraint and seat back designs, but the recommendation has never been adopted. Australia, which started with the same standards as the U.S., upgraded its requirements to a minimum head restraint height of 28 inches, even for adjustable restraints in the down position.

  ‘Catcher’s Mitt’ Seats

  Delphi Automotive Systems, formerly a part of General Motors, has a unified seat and head restraint that it claims will reduce the risk of whiplash and other injuries by 40 percent. The redesigned seat, which will allow the head and body to move together in a rear impact, was initially introduced in 1998 on cars produced by GM’s Swedish partner, Saab. The 2000 Buick LeSabre is the first domestic car to offer the “Catcher’s Mitt” seat.

• #5 by forever2004 on June 9th, 2010

  Quote

  

  One mile per hour.

• #6 by machrisr2000 on June 9th, 2010

  Quote

  

  There is no “established” speed for soft tissue injuries to occur. The main problem is that there is a lot of money to be made in soft tissue injuries by chiropractors, doctors and lawyers, and a lot of money to be lost for insurance companies. Therefore, there are experts all over the map on this question. Many of them are more interested in their own bottom line than in correctly determining whether an injury could have occurred.

  1 or 2 mph is not going to do it. Reputable biomechanical experts say that about 7 mph is the lowest threshhold, and even at that speed most people will not get soft tissue neck injuries. Rear end crashes are less likely than most to cause this injury because most cars have a headrest that prevents the overextension necessary. If the impact is high enough, however, a person’s head will be pushed back and then rock forward with sufficient force to cause soft tissue injuries anyway.

  Another important factor is suceptability. Elderly people or people who have chronic neck (and back) problems will experience soft tissue injuries with less impact than healthy people.

  When it comes to making insurance claims, anyone can find a chiropractor who will say that someone can get injured with any impact at all. However, most insurance companies will deny the claim if its just a few miles per hour.

• #7 by davega7 on June 9th, 2010

  Quote

  

  You can get whiplash at any speed. It all depends on how you hit and whether or not your neck “whipped” enough. I got whiplash in the dumbest way. I was driving down my street and literally 4 houses down from me, while I was looking down at the radio, I had strayed just enough to the side to hit a parked car. Talk about embarrassing!! I was only going 5mph though. I hit the other car and my airbag came out. The airbag gave me massive whiplash and literally knocked me out for a few seconds and it also gave me burns up and down my arms from the force that it comes out with. A year or so later I ended up having to get surgery on a herniated disc in my neck which was directly related to the airbag giving me whiplash. I also learned why they say kids under a certain height and under the age of 12 should ride in the back seat if there are airbags in front.

• Pingback: Statistics on injuries from auto impacts under 10 miles per hour | The Wealth Of Health

• Pingback: Speed of impact to cause whiplash | The Wealth Of Health

• #8 by Rebecca on September 8th, 2010

  Quote

  

  I was just looking for information on whiplash because there is a similiar situation someone is claiming on a relative of mine. She hit him going about 4 to 5 miles per hour. They were both at a stop light and he started to go and make a right turn but then he stopped she tapped him, he was in a GMC colorado and my relative was in a 93 Ford Escort. You do the math!!!
  I have come to the conclusions everybody has a different answer for information on whiplash and I’m sorry it is absolutely ridiculous. I do believe there is a such thing as whiplash but if it cannot really be determined by a physician and /or x-rays than its a scam and people know that and thats why they are saying whiplash because it cant be determined.It makes more sense to have whiplash at a high rate of speed more like 40 to50 mph slammed in the rear. That makes sense, 4,5,even 10, Im not convinced, I think someones just trying to get a payout and it makes me sick. Those fakersjust make it hard for the people that are really injured and make it so we pay out more in tax dollars somewhere down the road, Because of all the fraud, no wonder California is so ridiculously high on everything.
  This message is to people who are trying to come up on the insurance companies and regular people like me just trying to make it. I hope you get caught and have to go to jail or pay back every cent of money you stole or tried to steal or both but I hope you pay for your B.S scam and hopefully someone beats you real good at your own shady game.

• Trackback: durian

• Trackback: Soffe shorts

• Trackback: sol yours truly